There is one quote from The Song of Achilles by Madeline Miller that my basic bitch heart loves: ‘I could recognise him by touch alone, by smell; I would know him blind, by the way his breaths came and his feet struck the earth. I would know him in death, at the end of the world.’ – so I was gagging to read it. Here is my honest and truthful review of the book.
I had read Madeline Miller’s other book Circe previously, and honestly, I wasn’t too impressed. Like The Song of Achilles, it’s based on a character in Greek mythology, a nymph called Circe, who gets exiled on an island and becomes one with nature. I had read SO many good reviews about it that I had spent the whole book waiting for it to get ‘good’ only to realise that was it. It was just a plain story, it was fine and I was sceptical if Song of Achilles would go the same way.
You: Should I read Song of Achilles?
Yes. Oh god yes. I freaking loved it. Although if the last paragraph in the book didn’t exist, i would’ve HATED it. But I loved it. I’m a fan, will totally reread it. I read the last chapter while waiting for my friends to come over and I was literally tearing up but held it together. Can you imagine if my friends turned up to me crying and they’re like, what’s wrong? And I’m like, I just read a really romantic book? So unhinged lol.
What’s good about Song of Achilles?
- I loved that there was no doubt of the bond and love between Patroclus and Achilles. They were both always devoted and truly only had eyes for another. I don’t really like the dynamic where there is miscommunication about feelings, and they spend the whole story trying to work out if the other likes them or not, but it’s a really popular trope. Having a couple that actually figures it out real early on and then spend the whole time actually really loyal to another and always trying to find another is so sweet.
- I like that the golden boy Achilles somehow was so in love with Patroclus, despite Patroclus calling himself a plain Jane. I think unlike the book Verity, who also seems to follow the hot man falling in love with plain Jane narrative which I fucking hated (read my review here), I can see why Achilles likes him, and I like Patroclus as the narrator. Patroclus is calm, loyal, wants to protect and help Achilles and the people around him. He doesn’t complain.
- I really liked that the gods and mythology were woven in like real people and characters. Magic is just accepted – after all, Achilles is made of magic (son of a goddess) so it has to be real. I’m going to sound like a ponce for this sentence: it reminds me of my time in Greece – the dreamy, ancient feel where the myths and legends are spoken about like history. Why is Athens called Athens? Because the goddess Athena won a contest and so it’s called Athens. Stated like a fact by everyone and yet so magical. There’s no other explanation. Not like ‘because some English person landed on it and called it after a place back home’. I loved that in the book, like how they just see goddesses and gods.
- It’s just so cute how much they love each other. Both of them equally just wanted to stay together. A lot of cute quotes in there. I feel like you can feel the love. It’s sweet.
- I also thought it was a great retelling of the Iliad. It really made it more digestible and real.
What’s bad about The Song of Achilles
- If you were actually a Greek mythology buff who wants it to be correct to the legend, you might not like this
- Gets a bit confusing with all the Greek names (but honestly, all you need to truly remember is Achilles, Patroclus, Thetis)
- The main romantic quote is not even at a romantic moment??? It’s just Patroclus recognising Achilles when he’s in disguise. I thought this was going to be a scene that was super emotional, maybe at the end. No, he’s just sitting at dinner looking at someone and being like ‘hey… that looks like Achilles’. I guess it’s supposed to show how he’s already so devoted and it’s just the beginning, but the scene was just such a non-emotional one when the quote by itself is wedding ceremony-worthy.
I seriously loved the book. It’s got mixed reviews but hey – I have a very mainstream taste and read a LOT of books, and this one was basically making me cry. Great to read once you get into it. Read it!!
Join the mailing list via the sign up box next to this post and never miss a blog post again! Plus, think of all the time you’ll save not refreshing the blog every five minutes. You could use that time to learn how to knit tiny hats for your cat.